The Best Boutique Hotels in Amagansett, NY

Posted by From Where on

Get Verified

Amagansett, New York offers a relaxed and refined Hamptons experience, blending pristine beaches, coastal charm, and understated luxury. Known for its quiet atmosphere and scenic surroundings, the area features a curated selection of boutique hotels and intimate stays that reflect both elegance and simplicity.

To identify the best boutique hotels in Amagansett, NY, our editorial team evaluated guest reviews across major platforms, overall ratings, design and guest experience, and location appeal. The properties below stand out for their distinctive atmosphere and memorable stays.

The Best Boutique Hotels in Amagansett, NY

Topping Rose House

Book Now

4.33 Stars 1,611 reviews

Topping Rose House is a luxury boutique property that combines historic charm with modern sophistication. Guests often highlight its elegant design, spacious grounds, and high-end dining experience.

1770 House Restaurant & Inn

Book Now

4.6 Stars 1,201 reviews

1770 House Restaurant & Inn offers a classic Hamptons stay with a focus on history and hospitality. Visitors frequently mention its cozy atmosphere and well-regarded on-site restaurant.

Marram

Book Now

4.33 Stars 1,414 reviews

Marram is a design-forward beachfront hotel known for its minimalist aesthetic and connection to nature. Guests often appreciate its serene setting and direct beach access.

The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

Book Now

4.46 Stars 1,164 reviews

The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages delivers a classic coastal resort experience with a boutique feel. Visitors frequently highlight its scenic waterfront location and relaxed atmosphere.

The Montauk Beach House

Book Now

4.37 Stars 1,287 reviews

The Montauk Beach House offers a lively boutique experience with a modern coastal vibe. Visitors frequently highlight its stylish design and vibrant social atmosphere.

Sunset Beach Hotel

Book Now

4.51 Stars 3,273 reviews

Sunset Beach Hotel is a well-known boutique property offering a relaxed beachfront experience. Guests often mention its scenic views and laid-back atmosphere.

Wavecrest Resort

Book Now

4.31 Stars 1,286 reviews

Wavecrest Resort provides a peaceful oceanfront stay with simple and comfortable accommodations. Visitors frequently appreciate its quiet setting and proximity to the beach.

← Older Post Newer Post →

Explore Top 20 Cities

Best Boutique Hotel

The Best Boutique Hotels in St. Petersburg–Clearwater, FL

The Best Boutique Hotels in St. Petersburg–Clearwater, FL

By From Where

St. Petersburg–Clearwater, Florida offers some of the Gulf Coast’s most beautiful beaches, vibrant waterfronts, and a relaxed coastal lifestyle. Known for its white-sand shores, sunny...

Read more
The Best Boutique Hotels in Fayetteville, AR

The Best Boutique Hotels in Fayetteville, AR

By From Where

Fayetteville, Arkansas blends a lively college-town atmosphere with scenic natural surroundings and a growing arts and culture scene. Located in Northwest Arkansas and home to...

Read more